SOP’s QUESTion Box Presents: What Was the First Rock In Your Country? Part 2

This question comes from a local fifth-grader, courtesy of the Science Outreach Program’s (SOP) question box. Teams from the Science Outreach Program make weekly visits to elementary school classrooms in the Portland area to encourage scientific learning in younger students—most importantly, by making it fun. One of the ways they do this is by having a question box, where any student can submit a question they have about the world, and the Science Outreach team will explore the answer with them. Now, this spirit of curiosity has taken on a new form in the Quest. If you have any serious SOP questions, please contact scienceoutreach@reed.edu, but if you just have a silly science question you’ve always wanted answered, we have a Reedie question box in the shape of a turtle outside of Bio 246. Drop us a question!

In last week’s exciting edition of SOPxQuest we discussed how the oldest rocks on earth are found in the tectonically stable centers of continental plates. Today, we’ll finally go over the list and answer the question of “what was the first rock in your country?” I won’t give a complete list of the oldest rock in every country, but I’ll go over some of the top contenders.

Brazil holds the title for Oldest Rock in South America, at 3.4 billion years. The Barberton Greenstone Belt in South Africa clocks in with samples that are 3.5 billion years old. Narrowly beating this impressive age, rocks found in Morton, Minnesota, USA were measured to be 3.55 billion years old. Greenland has some of the oldest sedimentary rocks, at 3.7 billion years, which might contain the oldest evidence for life on earth in the form of chemical residues. Finally, the Canadians may be proud to know that they hold the title for both second oldest and oldest rocks on Earth. In the Northwest Territories, there’s a (mostly yet to be explored) deposit which may contain rocks up to 3.95 billion years old, and in the region of Nuvvuagittuq, Quebec, samples have been found with ages up to 4.3 billion years old. So there you have it: a rare win for Quebec supremacists. 

However, there’s one country not on this list which might feel like a bit of a sore loser. The Jack Hills region of Western Australia is home to some fragments of zircon minerals which were found to be 4.4 billion years old! That’s only 100 million years after the formation of the Earth! This clearly should then be the winner, no? Well, our question writer clearly stated that they wanted to know what the first rock was in each country, not the oldest mineral. Minerals are made up of only a single chemical compound (in the Australian case zirconium silicate, ZrSiO4) while rocks are necessarily an aggregate of more than one. So, strictly speaking, these Australian chunks of Earth are the oldest minerals, but not the oldest rocks. 

Now, lobbing around billion (with a capitol B) like we’ve been doing might make these ages seem unimpressive. To put this in perspective, one might consider that if you made $1 a second (your hourly wage being a strong $3600/hr), and worked a standard 40-hour work week, it would take you 133 years to become a billionaire. Alternatively, taking the average two-story house to be ~7 meters tall, you would need to fill up two whole houses with sand in order to get to a billion grains. So, basically, these are some really old rocks. 

One might think that a question as obsessed with the past as this one would have been settled long ago, but a discovery was made as recently as 2019 which may have surpassed Canada’s winner in age. Because of all the geologic activity on Earth, it gets increasingly rare for rocks to survive without getting subducted into the mantle. 

However, there are places which experience no tectonic activity, where we can find even older rocks! Amazingly, the oldest rocks from Earth are not to be found on Earth but rather on our nearest stellar neighbor, the Moon. In 1971, Apollo 14 landed on the moon, and aside from leaving a bunch of junk, they also took some rocks home as keepsakes. One of these, Lunar Sample 14321, better known as "Big Bertha" (the 3rd largest Moon rock recovered, behind “Big Muley” and “Great Scott”) was found to have a chemical composition significantly different than that of the rest of the lunar material previously studied. Indeed, it appeared suspiciously similar to an Earth rock. In 2019, to much fanfare, scientists at NASA concluded that this rock was the oldest Earth rock ever found. 

In a dramatic twist of events, however, another study by a different group of scientists was published the following year which concluded that the granite sample was not terrestrial in origin, and just happened to have some quirks about it which made it stick out. They claimed upon closer analysis that there were many chemical similarities linking “Big Bertha” to other lunar rocks, which cast doubt on NASA’s initial interpretation. It seems likely this debate will continue, and until it is concluded, we will not decisively know ‘What is the first Earth rock?’

But if we’ve opened the door to outer space, then we might refine our question to be ‘Which country currently houses the oldest rock?’ That is, if we don’t care about where the rock came from, our winner then becomes “NWA 11119,” the oldest dated whole rock. The name derives from Northwestern Africa (not the band) as it was found in Mauritania, and the rock itself is 4.5648 billion years old. This rock was chemically formed in outer space before Earth had even come into existence, and so perhaps little Mauritania should get the title of ‘Oldest Rock’ for being the lucky recipient of a meteorite impact which brought NWA 11119 down to Earth. Of course, colonialism ran its course, and NWA 11119 is now (as of 2018) housed in the Maine Mineral and Gem Museum in the good ol’ US of A after being studied at UNM in Albuquerque. Does this mean the U.S. gets the title of oldest rock? Probably not, in my opinion. 

But if we had to pick an answer to “What Was the First Rock In Your Country?”, assuming this was asked to an American by our Portland schoolchild, and assuming by ‘first’ we mean ‘scientifically declared oldest,’ and not ‘what was here first’ (which would be Turtle Island) then I think NWA 11119 at 4.56 billion years old is the best answer. 

Previous
Previous

Something Gay: Gay Bathhouse!

Next
Next

Friday Tea Time: Sometimes, All It Takes Is a Cup of Tea