Faculty Beat is Talking about AI

At the faculty meeting on November 16, more than half of the time was spent discussing the proposed college-wide AI policy. Other topics of discussion included a positive update regarding federal policies for international students, the email sent out last week about antisemitism, changes to the studio art major, and inclusive hiring practices.

The meeting began with the unanimous approval of the minutes from the September 14, September 23, and October 12 faculty meetings. President Audrey Bilger then shared the president’s report. First, she shared how wonderful it was to see people on campus last week for Parent and Family Weekend and expressed her appreciation to those faculty who participated in programming. She then shared an update on the litigation regarding international students’ Duration of Status. Thanks to advocacy by the Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration, to which Reed belongs, a court recently ruled against the Department of Homeland Security ruling, upholding the existing Duration of Status rule. This ruling will continue to allow international students under certain visas to stay in the country for the duration of their education (see the September 14 Faculty Beat for more information on this).

Bilger also acknowledged the email sent out last Friday from Title VI, Title IX, and 504 Coordinator Christy Martin titled “Reed’s Commitment to a Community Free from Antisemitism.” Bilger said that she is listening and wants to take feedback seriously. She said that the email was an annual statement regarding Reed’s commitment to preventing antisemitism; part of the Office for Civil Rights settlement was an agreement to send out this annual statement. Bilger emphasized that, in addition to preventing antisemitism, Reed still wants to protect students of other protected classes and remains deeply committed to protecting freedom of speech and academic freedom.

Professor of Music Morgan Luker asked about the part of the email that encourages community members to report incidents even if they are unsure if that conduct meets the policy’s definition. He said that he was caught off guard by what he read as an encouragement to report on one another, which he said feels like it goes against Reed’s efforts to create an inclusive community and look out for one another. Luker asked how Bilger encouraged the community to make sense of these kinds of recommendations. Bilger said that the intent is to ensure that people understand that the college wants to hear about people’s experience with bias, especially given that the origins of the OCR resolution were complaints by two students who experienced bias at Reed that were unresolved while they attended. She said that the college wants to make it clear that they take reports seriously, but they are not encouraging people to make frivolous reports. Bilger reiterated that they are listening to feedback and will take it into consideration. 

Professor of Anthropology Charlene Makley also asked about this part of the email: was it stipulated by the OCR settlement, or was it an addition? Dean of the Faculty Kathy Oleson said she is not positive about the specific wording, but clarified that the intent was to lower the bar so that people can come forward if they have concerns. She said that it was not meant to encourage ratting on our friends, but rather to improve responses to situations (such as when something happens in class that makes people uncomfortable) in order to improve the campus environment and make classrooms an inclusive space. Oleson also said that there are things that happen on campus that those in charge don’t hear about, and they want to hear about them before they become something bigger.

Oleson then provided the dean’s report. She shared that the college is continuing to look at the long-term budget, since Reed is spending more money than it receives back. Around the college, different areas are talking about it: central changes that impact the whole campus; administrative, non-academic units; and instructional, academic changes, which are being led by the Committee on Academic Policy and Planning (CAPP). The next step regarding academic budget changes is for CAPP and Oleson to meet with divisions. She also shared that there is a new data page on the website. Finally, she invited up Professor of English Kritish Rajbhandari, who shared that the Greenberg speaker this spring will be prominent Indian writer Amitav Ghosh.

Next to speak was Professor of Physics Alison Crocker on behalf of CAPP. First, she brought a few new courses for approval, which were approved unanimously. She also shared a proposed change to the requirements for the major in Art with a Concentration in Studio Art, changing the requirements of what students have to do before the junior qual from two 100-level and one 300-level studio art classes to three studio art classes at any level. This change was also approved unanimously.

The next order of business was a proposed motion to adopt a college-wide policy on AI, brought by the Ad Hoc Committee on AI through CAPP. The motion would add language to the Faculty Code stating that there is a default policy on AI usage, changes to which must be approved by the faculty, and that faculty must either note that they are following that default policy or designate their own course policy in their syllabi (if they do not specify, the default policy applies). It also adds a section to the catalog with the default AI policy. The catalog addition includes a lengthy definition of what qualifies as AI and essentially says that students are prohibited from using AI in any Reed coursework unless otherwise specified in the syllabus.The full policy should be available online soon, and will be published in the following issue of the Quest.

First, Professor of Computer Science Adam Groce, who is Co-Chair of the Ad Hoc Committee on AI, shared a proposed amendment to the policy based on feedback that the committee received on the original version. The amendment corrected details that were open to interpretation, primarily by adding a definition of coursework in addition to the definition of AI and by elaborating on the definition of AI. This amendment was approved unanimously. The faculty then entered into a 40-minute discussion of the proposed AI policy.

Multiple professors expressed their appreciation to the committee for their work on this policy. A few had minor questions on how it would be revised (requires a majority vote of the faculty), when it would go into effect (next semester), how unique this approach is (unclear, the environment is changing rapidly), and whether it relies on or affects the software we have (no, it was written to be distinct from software choices).

There were several other minor topics of discussion. Professor of Philosophy Paul Hovda asked about cases that are unclear whether they fall under this definition, like Googling a technical term and reading the AI overview. Groce said that there is an unavoidable fuzzy line when writing a policy like this. Two professors asked about how this policy will be enforced in practice when it comes to academic misconduct cases, and Bilger said that is a matter that the Ad Hoc Committee on Academic Misconduct is discussing. One asked if this proposed policy had been shared with students, and Groce said it was, and they were generally in support, though there were a variety of opinions. Professor of Anthropology Charlene Makley expressed frustrations about a previous AI training that felt business-oriented and incorrect, and asked if there could be a training tool more geared toward Reed in the future. 

Several professors shared thoughts about how this policy applies to the thesis. The policy states that AI may only be used on theses with the agreement of the student and the thesis advisor, and that any AI usage on thesis requires a disclosure. Professor of German Jake Fraser prompted discussion on whether there should be some limit to how much AI can be used in the thesis. Others pointed out that the thesis is not just about the advisor since it also has to be approved by the department—what if the committee disagrees about the amount of appropriate AI usage? No conclusion was reached.

Other major topics of discussion included how to prepare students for going into a workforce that is increasingly using AI, the lack of a corresponding faculty policy on AI, and the image this policy presents.

Professor of Mathematics Kyle Ormsby said that there are many substantive valid potential uses of these tools, and that many faculty are experimenting with this—he pointed out that around 40 faculty are meeting monthly through the Center for Teaching and Learning (CTL) to discuss how these tools might apply to pedagogy and research and how to incorporate them. However, he expressed his opinion that this policy is not a statement that Reed hates this technology, but rather that there are many courses that will choose not to use it. He hopes that faculty will be mindful of other faculty’s prerogative to choose course-specific proposals.

Professor of Psychology Greg Jensen said that he has recently been in communication with students and alumni regarding letters of recommendation, and he is hearing that with the exception of students working in wet labs, they are saying that at least 40% of their jobs are AI use. He said that although he currently follows essentially the proposed default AI policy, faculty should be aware of what AI can do and explain to students what they want them to be learning in contrast with what AI is being used for in their fields. He encouraged faculty to pay more attention to what this technology does so we are not setting students up for a difficult entry into the job market.

Similarly, one professor shared that she recently sat on a panel where proposals that did not use AI were effectively not to be discussed. She also expressed that having a policy that faculty would never adhere to themselves signals a level of hypocrisy. She said that, when interacting with parents in admission events last spring, the number one question was how Reed faculty are dealing with AI, and this statement feels like a copout and shows hypocrisy.

Professor of Biology Sarah Schaack pointed out that Reed doesn’t have different smoking policies for students and for faculty or staff, and said that it feels strange to have an AI policy for students that would not also be the practice for faculty and staff. Another professor said faculty should also have an AI policy, because some temptations are universal.

Professor of Political Science Chris Koski expressed several concerns about the policy. He said that it seems to be a specific symbolic statement about AI use in general that he sees as looking the wrong direction. He thinks that this policy would have to be updated with some frequency, and is unsure if faculty will be able to update it with the frequency it needs. He echoed concerns about the lack of a matching faculty policy. He said that this is going to send a particular signal to students about how faculty thinks they should think about AI. Students will want faculty to be held to their standard, but there are a lot of reasons why faculty should have their own standard, Koski said.

Another professor expressed disappointment that Reed is an AI-policy-forward institution. She would prefer to lead with a message about what Reed thinks education is about in this new era, rather than leading with just the AI policy.

Groce shared thoughts in favor of the policy throughout the discussion. He said that it’s difficult to communicate both that AI is a useful tool and that it can be a real danger to students’ education. One advantage of the policy, he said, is that it lets us have a reference point regarding what counts as AI in order to educate students when they arrive at Reed. He also said that the committee imagines the website that will be created about this policy will also include alternate language that faculty can use to adopt more AI-friendly policies. As a computer science professor, he said that he knows that his students will graduate and use AI. However, for the same reason that he likes calculators but does not think that third graders should be using calculators when they are learning to multiply numbers, he doesn’t think students should be using AI in introductory CS classes. He said that the goal of the policy is to make it clear and let people do what’s best for them pedagogically course by course.

Ultimately, the proposed policy was passed, though with a vocal minority of opposition.

Next, Professor of Mathematics Angélica Osorno shared the report from the Committee on Advancement and Tenure (CAT). Faculty evaluations will open on Moodle soon, and she reminded faculty to spend time in class having students fill out the evaluations and to remind students which evaluation goes to CAT and which goes to the professor. She also shared that the motion to approve the revised language on teaching and service (discussed at the last faculty meeting) was approved via electronic ballot. CAT is still accepting letters of recommendation, she said. Finally, Osorno said that CAT and CAPP are temporarily pausing the target of opportunity procedure.

The final speaker was Professor of Chemistry Mir Bowring, Chair of the Faculty Committee on Diversity (COD). They shared that the job of COD is to take grand statements about diversity and anti-racism and try to make them happen, including making recommendations to faculty. They discussed several ongoing initiatives, including community building, improving institutional response for faculty who have been harmed, faculty hiring, amplifying ongoing efforts, and collaboration with other campus bodies. They also promoted faculty/staff affinity groups, which one can join via the OID website. 

Bowring then invited Mary James, Emeritus Professor of Physics, to talk about the history of inclusive hiring practices at Reed. James said that when she was hired at Reed in 1988, she was one of two people of color and the only African American on the tenure track; it took five more years for a second tenure track African American professor, and another five years for a third. In 2001, Reed began to institute thoughtful, inclusive hiring practices that emphasize not only inclusive practices in evaluating candidates, but also pre-search preparation to think expansively and find a diverse range of candidates. James said that if Reed wants to continue to cultivate diverse faculty into the future, they have to hire them now. If one started on the tenure track now and served as long as she did, they’d retire in 2061.

Bowring encouraged faculty to check their biases, work continually against their own biases, recruit large pools of candidates, and avoid tokenizing candidates. They said that Reed is at 16% underrepresented faculty on the tenure track and showed a graph demonstrating a very slow but real increase over the past ten years. Long-term planning is critical, they said; they urged faculty to think ahead to when they are hiring years down the line.

After that, there was no new business, so with that, the meeting was adjourned. The next faculty meeting will be held on Monday, December 7. Students interested in attending should email presidentsoffice@reed.edu.

Maggie Feinberg

is a freshman history major. After four years in various editorial roles on their high school newspaper, they're excited to be writing and photographing for the Quest, covering faculty beat and occasional forays into other topics. They can often be found procrastinating on homework, going down rabbit holes, or fire spinning with Weapons of Mass Distraction.

Previous
Previous

Senate Beat is Graffitiing the Library

Next
Next

Quest-en-Scène: La Bola Negra Is A Fresh Take On The Queer Historical Drama